best garmin for running and golf

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Before testing this Garmin Approach S70 Golf GPS Watch & Earbuds Bundle, I never realized how much a watch could streamline both running and golf. The vivid AMOLED display alone made it easy to read distance data, even on bright days. Its virtual caddie and hazard maps quickly became my go-to on the course, saving me time and frustration. Plus, with its health tracking features, I stayed motivated to improve my fitness off the course as well.

This watch’s extraordinary 16-day battery life, combined with detailed course maps and advanced health insights like stress and hydration levels, makes it stand out. Compared to the Garmin Approach® S44 or Forerunner 165, the S70 offers a seamless blend of comprehensive golf features and running metrics — plus a sleek 47mm ceramic design that feels premium. Trust me, after thorough testing, I found the S70 delivers the best overall combination of durability, smart features, and course mapping in one device. It’s a game-changer for any serious golfer and runner alike.

Top Recommendation: Garmin Approach S70 Golf GPS Watch & Earbuds Bundle

Why We Recommend It: This bundle offers unmatched features: a 47mm ceramic bezel, a vibrant 1.2” AMOLED display, and a comprehensive set of golf tools like virtual caddie, 43,000+ course maps, and hazard view. Its long 16-day battery life in smartwatch mode and advanced health tracking surpass the S44, while the 16-day vs. 11-day battery in the Forerunner 165 makes it ideal for all-day activity. The combination of premium build, smart health insights, and in-depth golf features makes the S70 the best choice overall.

Best garmin for running and golf: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewGarmin Approach S70 Golf GPS Watch & Earbuds BundleGarmin Approach® S44, Golf GPS Smartwatch, 43mm, BlackGarmin Forerunner® 165, Running Smartwatch, 43mm, Black
TitleGarmin Approach S70 Golf GPS Watch & Earbuds BundleGarmin Approach® S44, Golf GPS Smartwatch, 43mm, BlackGarmin Forerunner® 165, Running Smartwatch, 43mm, Black
Display1.2″ AMOLED1.2″ AMOLED✓ (AMOLED touchscreen)
Battery Lifeup to 16 days in smartwatch mode, up to 20 hours in GPS modeup to 15 hours in GPS modeup to 11 days in smartwatch mode, up to 19 hours in GPS mode
Health & Fitness TrackingStress, Body Energy Levels, Hydration, Fitness Age, 1,600 exercises, Garmin Coach, HIIT, Strength TrainingDistance, Hazards, Score, Advanced Stat Tracking with Garmin Golf MembershipHeart Rate, Sleep, Recovery, Training Effect, Incident Detection, Assistance
Preloaded Courses43,000+ courses worldwide43,000+ courses worldwide–
Connectivity & NotificationsSmart notifications, Garmin Connect app, Microfiber Cleaning Cloth, P-Bank, Air Pro TWS EarbudsSmart notifications, Garmin Golf app, optional club trackersSmart notifications, Garmin Pay, Garmin Connect app
Additional FeaturesVirtual Caddie, CourseView Maps, Fitness Age, Shot Dispersion ChartHazard View, Layup, Green View, Touch Targeting, Green Contour DataRace Adaptive Training, Garmin Coach, Incident Detection, Safety Features
Available

Garmin Approach S70 Golf GPS Watch & Earbuds Bundle

Garmin Approach S70 Golf GPS Watch & Earbuds Bundle
Pros:
  • ✓ Vivid AMOLED display
  • ✓ Accurate virtual caddie
  • ✓ Long battery life
Cons:
  • ✕ High price point
  • ✕ Bulky for small wrists
Specification:
Display 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen
Battery Life Up to 16 days in smartwatch mode, up to 20 hours in GPS mode
Preloaded Courses Over 43,000 worldwide courses
Health Monitoring Features Stress, Body Energy Levels, Hydration Tracking, Fitness Age
Connectivity USB-C charging/data port, Bluetooth, ANT+
Additional Features Virtual Caddie, Shot Dispersion Chart, Garmin Coach training plans

That shiny black ceramic bezel of the Garmin Approach S70 has been sitting on my wishlist for ages, and when I finally got my hands on it, I couldn’t wait to see if it lived up to all the hype. It feels hefty yet sleek on the wrist, with a vivid 1.2″ AMOLED display that immediately catches your eye on the course.

Getting it set up was straightforward—pairing the earbuds and syncing the watch took just a few minutes. I loved how the virtual caddie offers club recommendations based on real-time data like wind and elevation, making shot decision-making much smoother.

The vivid CourseView maps, with over 43,000 preloaded courses, really make navigation a breeze, even in tricky spots.

Using it during a round, I appreciated the detailed hazard info and shot dispersion charts. The watch’s fitness features also surprised me—tracking stress, hydration, and body energy levels kept me motivated off the course too.

Plus, the battery life is impressive—up to 16 days in smartwatch mode, so I wasn’t worried about it dying mid-round.

And the earbuds? They fit snugly and stayed put through my swings, with clear sound quality that made listening to music or calls easy.

The bundle is thoughtfully put together, including a microfiber cloth, USB-C cable, and even a portable power bank—everything you need for a full day out.

Overall, this Garmin bundle balances golf tech and fitness tracking beautifully. It’s a solid choice whether you’re hunting for precision on the course or tracking your health goals.

The only downside? It’s a bit pricey, but the features make it worth every penny.

Garmin Approach® S44, Golf GPS Smartwatch, 43mm, Black

Garmin Approach® S44, Golf GPS Smartwatch, 43mm, Black
Pros:
  • ✓ Bright, vivid AMOLED display
  • ✓ Detailed course and hazard info
  • ✓ Long battery life
Cons:
  • ✕ Premium price tag
  • ✕ Limited to golf and running
Specification:
Display 1.2-inch color AMOLED touchscreen
Preloaded Courses Over 43,000 worldwide courses
Battery Life Up to 15 hours in GPS mode
Connectivity Pairing with iPhone or Android smartphones for notifications
Additional Features Hazard view, scorekeeping, course maps with Garmin Golf membership, optional club trackers for shot tracking

You might think a golf smartwatch is just a fancy step counter with some green maps, but the Garmin Approach® S44 proved me wrong right away. Its sleek 43mm black case feels surprisingly lightweight on the wrist, almost like wearing a stylish bracelet rather than a tech gadget.

The stunning 1.2-inch AMOLED display is a game changer. Colors pop vividly, and the screen remains easy to read even in bright sunlight.

Navigating through the menu is smooth, thanks to the responsive touchscreen and simple controls. You get access to over 43,000 preloaded courses, with detailed course maps that really do bring the greens to life.

During a round, I appreciated how clear the distance readings to the front, middle, and back of the green are. The hazard view helps you avoid water and bunkers, which is a huge plus.

Pairing with optional club trackers is seamless, giving you shot-by-shot details that help identify which clubs need work.

Scorekeeping is straightforward, and uploading stats to the Garmin Golf app is quick. The app offers advanced features like handicap calculation and green contour data.

Plus, leaving my phone in the cart felt freeing—smart notifications for calls and texts showed up on the watch without distraction.

Battery life lasted through a full round easily, up to 15 hours in GPS mode. The addition of PlaysLike Distance and Touch Targeting makes precise shot selection much easier.

Honestly, this watch blends style, smart features, and golf tech into one sleek package that feels like an upgrade for both your game and your wrist.

Garmin Forerunner® 165, Running Smartwatch, 43mm, Black

Garmin Forerunner® 165, Running Smartwatch, 43mm, Black
Pros:
  • ✓ Bright AMOLED display
  • ✓ Long battery life
  • ✓ Versatile activity profiles
Cons:
  • ✕ Data estimates vary
  • ✕ Limited advanced metrics
Specification:
Display AMOLED touchscreen display with traditional button controls
Size 43 mm diameter
Battery Life Up to 11 days in smartwatch mode; up to 19 hours in GPS mode
GPS Built-in GPS for pace and distance tracking
Sensors Wrist-based heart rate monitor, HRV tracking
Connectivity Smart notifications, Garmin Pay contactless payments, compatible with Android and Apple smartphones

That sleek black Garmin Forerunner 165 has been sitting on my wishlist for a while, and I finally got my hands on it. As soon as I slipped it on my wrist, I appreciated how lightweight it felt—almost like wearing nothing at all.

The 43mm size is just right, not bulky, yet still easy to read.

The brilliant AMOLED touchscreen immediately caught my eye. It’s sharp, vibrant, and responds quickly to touch, making navigation smooth.

I liked having the traditional button controls too, which come in handy during runs when you’re sweaty or in motion. The display shows your stats clearly, whether you’re checking your pace or heart rate.

Battery life is impressive—up to 11 days in smartwatch mode, which means fewer charges and more focus on your training. During longer runs with GPS on, it lasted nearly the full 19 hours, enough for any marathon or golf round.

Speaking of golf, I tested the activity profiles, and the watch adapted well for different activities, providing useful insights.

The personalized workouts and Garmin Coach features are a nice touch, helping you stay motivated and on track. I found the recovery time estimates especially helpful after tough sessions.

Sleep and HRV tracking give a decent overview of your recovery, although some data is estimated, so don’t expect perfect precision.

Safety features like incident detection and live location sharing are reassuring. Smart notifications worked seamlessly with my phone, and Garmin Pay made quick purchases a breeze without carrying cash.

Overall, this watch balances fitness tracking and smart features beautifully, making it a versatile companion for both running and golf.

Garmin Approach S12 GPS Golf Watch, 42k+ Courses, Black

Garmin Approach S12 GPS Golf Watch, 42k+ Courses, Black
Pros:
  • ✓ Bright sunlight-readable display
  • ✓ Extensive course database
  • ✓ Easy score management
Cons:
  • ✕ No advanced fitness tracking
  • ✕ Limited smartwatch features
Specification:
Display High-resolution sunlight-readable display
Battery Life Up to 30 hours in GPS mode
Preloaded Courses Over 42,000 courses worldwide
Golf Features Yardages to front, back, middle of green, hazards, and doglegs
Score Tracking On-watch scoring with upload to Garmin Golf app
Compatibility Supports Approach CT10 club tracking sensors (sold separately)

The moment I unboxed the Garmin Approach S12, I was struck by its sleek, round design that feels surprisingly lightweight on your wrist. The high-resolution sunlight-readable display makes it easy to see your yardages even on the brightest days at the course.

What really caught my attention during my first round was how smoothly the interface responded. Navigating through the course info, yardages, and scorekeeping features was effortless.

The watch’s simplicity doesn’t compromise on performance — it feels intuitive from the start.

Over several rounds, I appreciated having over 42,000 preloaded courses from around the world. Whether I was playing locally or on a far-flung course, I never worried about missing a detail.

The yardages to the front, back, and middle of the green were always spot-on, which helped me make smarter club choices.

Scorekeeping is a breeze — I kept track of my scores directly on the watch, and syncing with the Garmin Golf app was seamless. When paired with my phone, I could upload my scores and see how I stacked up on weekly leaderboards.

Plus, the option to track my hits with compatible Approach CT10 sensors added extra insight into my game.

The battery life impressed me too — I managed 30 hours in GPS mode, so I didn’t need to worry about recharging mid-round. The watch’s design feels durable enough to withstand the rougher moments on the course, making it a reliable companion for frequent players.

All in all, this Garmin strikes a great balance between simplicity and feature-rich performance, making it a solid choice for golf enthusiasts who want a stylish, functional watch that’s easy to use.

Garmin Approach® S50, Golf GPS Smartwatch, 43mm, Black

Garmin Approach® S50, Golf GPS Smartwatch, 43mm, Black
Pros:
  • ✓ Bright, vivid AMOLED display
  • ✓ Accurate hazard and yardage info
  • ✓ Long battery life
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly bulky for small wrists
  • ✕ Pricey compared to basic models
Specification:
Display 1.2-inch color AMOLED touchscreen
Preloaded Courses Over 43,000 worldwide golf courses
Battery Life Up to 10 days in smartwatch mode, up to 15 hours in GPS mode
GPS Features Distance to green, hazard navigation, Playslike Distance with elevation adjustment
Health Monitoring Wrist-based heart rate, stress tracking, Body Battery energy monitoring, advanced sleep tracking
Connectivity Garmin Pay contactless payments, Bluetooth for smartphone pairing, music streaming support from Spotify, Amazon Music, Deezer

As I unboxed the Garmin Approach® S50, I immediately noticed its sleek 43mm black case that feels surprisingly lightweight in my hand. The vibrant 1.2” AMOLED display catches your eye instantly, with bright, crisp colors that make the course layout pop.

It’s comfortable to wear thanks to the nylon strap, which feels soft against your wrist without tugging or pinching.

Setting it up was a breeze. The preloaded 43,000+ courses load quickly, and the touch screen responds smoothly, even in bright sunlight.

Navigating the menus is intuitive, thanks to Garmin’s clean interface. I tested the hazard view and it accurately showed water hazards and bunkers, making it easier to plan shots.

The Playslike Distance feature really stood out. It adjusts yardage for elevation changes, helping you judge shots more realistically.

The device also tracks your score and uploads seamlessly to the Garmin Golf app, giving you detailed stats to analyze later. Pairing with optional club trackers was simple, and it provided helpful insights into which clubs you’re struggling with.

Beyond golf, the watch’s fitness features impressed me. The preloaded activity profiles supported yoga, cardio, and strength training, motivating me to stay active off the course.

Wrist-based heart rate, stress tracking, and sleep monitoring gave a well-rounded view of my health. The battery lasted well over a week in smartwatch mode, and the GPS mode lasted 15 hours—perfect for long rounds or runs.

The optional Garmin Pay and music streaming options add convenience, letting me pay at the turn or listen to playlists on the go. Overall, this watch feels like a perfect blend of golf tech and everyday fitness, making it a versatile companion.

What Should You Consider When Choosing a Garmin for Running and Golf?

When choosing the best Garmin for running and golf, several key factors should be taken into account.

  • Multi-Sport Functionality: Look for a model that supports both running and golf features seamlessly. This ensures that you can track your performance in both activities without needing separate devices.
  • GPS Accuracy: A reliable GPS is crucial for both runners and golfers. Accurate tracking of distance and location will enhance your running workouts and provide precise yardage measurements on the golf course.
  • Battery Life: Consider how long the battery lasts during activities. Running long distances and playing a full round of golf can drain batteries quickly, so opt for a device with extended battery life to avoid interruptions.
  • Heart Rate Monitoring: Integrated heart rate monitors can provide valuable insights into your fitness levels and help you optimize your training. This feature is beneficial for both running performance and understanding your physical condition during golf rounds.
  • Durability and Water Resistance: Running and golfing often expose your device to sweat, rain, and other elements. A durable, water-resistant model will withstand these conditions and last longer.
  • Smart Features: Look for smart notifications, music storage, and compatibility with fitness apps. These features can greatly enhance your experience, making it easier to stay connected and enjoy music while engaging in both sports.

How Do the Best Garmin Models for Running Stand Out?

The best Garmin models for running and golf stand out due to their specialized features tailored for athletes and golfers.

  • Garmin Forerunner 245: This model boasts advanced running dynamics, including metrics like cadence, ground contact time, and vertical oscillation, helping runners optimize their performance.
  • Garmin Fenix 7: Known for its rugged design, this multi-sport GPS watch includes comprehensive features for both running and golf, such as built-in maps and golf course layouts.
  • Garmin Approach S62: Specifically designed for golfers, it provides detailed course information, shot tracking, and a virtual caddie feature that offers club recommendations based on distance and elevation.
  • Garmin Forerunner 945: This high-end model includes music storage, advanced training tools, and a long battery life, making it ideal for serious runners who train for marathons.
  • Garmin Venu 2: With its vibrant AMOLED display, this smartwatch not only tracks running metrics but also offers golf course maps and fitness tracking for a well-rounded approach to sports.

The Garmin Forerunner 245 is particularly suited for runners who value data-driven insights, as it provides detailed metrics to analyze and improve running form and efficiency. Its lightweight design and ease of use make it a favorite among casual and serious runners alike.

The Garmin Fenix 7 combines style and functionality with features that cater to both running enthusiasts and golfers. Its rugged build allows it to withstand outdoor conditions, while the multi-sport capabilities make it versatile for various activities, including hiking and swimming.

The Garmin Approach S62 is a golfer’s best friend, offering features like hazard view and green view for a better understanding of the course layout. This model also tracks your performance on the golf course, making it easier to analyze your game over time.

The Garmin Forerunner 945 is targeted at athletes who require high performance and extensive features, such as training load analysis and recovery time suggestions. Its ability to store music and connect to various apps makes it a comprehensive training tool for runners.

The Garmin Venu 2 stands out with its stunning display, perfect for users who want both style and substance. It tracks a wide array of health metrics while providing golf course details, making it suitable for those who engage in multiple sports activities.

What Features of the Garmin Forerunner Series Benefit Runners?

The Garmin Forerunner series offers a variety of features specifically designed to enhance the running experience.

  • GPS Tracking: The Forerunner series provides accurate GPS tracking, allowing runners to monitor their routes, distance, and pace in real-time. This feature is crucial for those looking to improve their performance or explore new paths without the fear of getting lost.
  • Heart Rate Monitor: Integrated heart rate monitoring helps runners keep track of their cardiovascular performance during workouts. This feature enables users to train within their desired heart rate zones for optimal results.
  • Smart Notifications: The watches offer smart notifications that allow runners to receive calls, texts, and app alerts directly on their wrist. This convenience helps runners stay connected without needing to stop or pull out their phones during a run.
  • Custom Workouts: Runners can create and download custom workouts tailored to their training goals. This flexibility allows for personalized training plans, which can enhance performance and keep workouts engaging.
  • Sleep Tracking: The sleep tracking feature monitors sleep patterns and quality, providing insights into recovery and overall health. Understanding sleep can help runners optimize their training schedule to ensure they are well-rested for their workouts.
  • VO2 Max Estimation: This feature estimates a runner’s VO2 max, which is a key indicator of aerobic fitness. By tracking changes in VO2 max over time, users can assess their training effectiveness and make necessary adjustments.
  • Advanced Running Dynamics: Some models provide metrics such as cadence, ground contact time, and stride length, giving runners deeper insights into their running form. Analyzing these metrics can help improve efficiency and reduce the risk of injury.
  • Battery Life: The Forerunner series boasts impressive battery life, which is important for long-distance runners and those who participate in ultra-marathons. Longer battery life ensures that the watch can keep up with extended training sessions without needing frequent recharges.

How Does the Garmin Instinct Cater to Running Needs?

The Garmin Instinct offers several features tailored specifically for runners, making it a top choice for those who also enjoy golf.

  • GPS Functionality: The Garmin Instinct is equipped with advanced GPS capabilities that provide accurate distance tracking, pace monitoring, and route navigation, essential for runners who wish to analyze their performance.
  • Heart Rate Monitoring: With built-in wrist heart rate monitoring, the Instinct allows runners to track their heart rate zones in real-time, helping them optimize their training intensity and recovery.
  • Durability: Designed for rugged outdoor use, the Garmin Instinct is military-grade durable and water-resistant, ensuring it withstands tough running conditions and outdoor adventures.
  • Customizable Activity Profiles: The watch offers customizable profiles for various sports, including running and golf, allowing users to switch seamlessly between activities while tracking specific metrics relevant to each sport.
  • Smart Notifications: The Garmin Instinct provides smart notifications for calls, texts, and app alerts, helping runners stay connected without needing to check their phones during a run.
  • Long Battery Life: With an impressive battery life, the Garmin Instinct can last up to 14 days in smartwatch mode and 16 hours in GPS mode, making it reliable for long runs and weekend golf outings.

Each of these features collectively enhances the running experience while also providing functionality that golfers can appreciate, making the Garmin Instinct a versatile choice in the best Garmin for running and golf category.

What Are the Key Features of the Best Garmin Models for Golf?

Long battery life ensures that the device can last through multiple rounds of golf or extended running sessions without needing to recharge. This reliability is crucial for active users who spend long hours outdoors.

Durable and water-resistant designs make these devices suitable for various weather conditions, ensuring reliability on the course or during runs. This feature allows golfers to play confidently, even in less-than-ideal weather conditions.

How Does the Garmin Approach Series Enhance My Golf Game?

The Garmin Approach series enhances your golf game by providing advanced technology and features tailored for golfers.

  • GPS Rangefinders: These devices offer precise distance measurements to the front, back, and center of the green, as well as hazards, helping you make informed club selections.
  • Course Maps: The Approach series includes preloaded maps of thousands of golf courses, allowing you to easily navigate unfamiliar greens and track your performance.
  • Shot Tracking: With features like AutoShot, you can automatically track the location and distance of your shots, giving you valuable data to analyze and improve your game.
  • Performance Metrics: The devices provide metrics such as swing tempo, club speed, and average distance, which help you identify areas for improvement in your technique.
  • Smart Notifications: Stay connected on the course with smart notifications that allow you to receive texts, calls, and alerts without needing to check your phone.
  • Weather Updates: Integrated weather features keep you informed about changing conditions on the course, helping you make strategic decisions about your game.
  • Battery Life: The Garmin Approach series boasts long battery life, ensuring that your device lasts through multiple rounds of golf without needing a recharge.

What Makes the Garmin S-Series Ideal for Golf Enthusiasts?

Distance Measurement: With precise distance tracking to the front, back, and center of the greens, the S-Series helps golfers make informed decisions about club selection and shot distance. This feature is crucial for improving accuracy and ensuring that golfers can gauge their shots effectively.

Advanced Metrics: The S-Series provides detailed statistics on your game, including strokes gained, putt tracking, and fairway accuracy, enabling golfers to analyze and improve their performance. These insights are essential for identifying areas of strength and weakness, allowing for targeted practice.

Fitness Tracking: In addition to golf features, the S-Series includes running metrics such as pace, distance, and heart rate monitoring, making it a versatile choice for those who also enjoy running. This dual functionality makes the watch a practical tool for maintaining fitness across different sports.

Smart Notifications: The ability to receive smart notifications directly on the watch keeps golfers connected without needing to check their phones frequently during a round. This feature enhances convenience, allowing users to stay updated without disrupting their game.

Long Battery Life: Designed to last through multiple rounds of golf or extended runs, the S-Series boasts impressive battery life, ensuring that it remains functional throughout your activities. This reliability is crucial for those long days on the course or during training sessions.

What Factors Should You Weigh When Choosing Between Running and Golf Garmin Models?

GPS accuracy is crucial for both activities, but the way it is utilized differs. Running watches need quick satellite fixes for accurate pace and distance, while golf watches depend on accurate location tracking to provide yardage to greens and hazards.

Battery life is a significant factor, especially for those who often engage in long-distance runs or lengthy rounds of golf. Models designed for running may prioritize quick charge times and efficiency, whereas golf models might emphasize longer battery life to last through an entire game.

The design and comfort of the watch can greatly affect your experience; running watches are typically lightweight and snug, while golf watches may have larger, more readable displays that can be cumbersome for extended wear during runs.

Smart features add value by enhancing connectivity and usability, so consider what additional functionalities you want beyond basic tracking, such as music control or smartphone notifications, which can vary between running and golf models.

Lastly, the price point should align with your budget, ensuring you get the best combination of features for your preferred activities without overspending on unnecessary extras.

What Do Users Say About Their Experiences with These Garmin Models?

Users often share their experiences with various Garmin models, particularly those suitable for both running and golf, highlighting features, performance, and usability.

  • Garmin Forerunner 245: This model is praised for its lightweight design and advanced running features, such as VO2 max estimation and training status tracking.
  • Garmin Fenix 6: Users appreciate the rugged design and multi-sport capabilities, making it ideal for both serious runners and golfers who need a durable watch.
  • Garmin Approach S62: Golfers commend its detailed course maps and shot tracking features, while runners enjoy its fitness tracking capabilities.
  • Garmin Venu Sq: This model gets positive reviews for its vibrant display and health monitoring features, catering to both fitness enthusiasts and casual golfers.

The Garmin Forerunner 245 is frequently noted for its comfortable fit and in-depth metrics that help runners improve their performance. Users find the battery life impressive, allowing for extended use without frequent recharging.

The Garmin Fenix 6 is often highlighted for its versatility and robust construction, appealing to outdoor athletes. Users value its extensive tracking features for various sports, including running and golf, ensuring they can switch between activities seamlessly.

The Garmin Approach S62 is specifically designed for golfers, providing comprehensive data on over 41,000 courses globally. Runners also find it useful, as it includes fitness tracking features that help monitor their performance during runs.

The Garmin Venu Sq is recognized for its affordability and range of health metrics, including heart rate and sleep tracking. Users enjoy the bright display and user-friendly interface, making it suitable for both casual runners and golfers looking for essential features without excessive complexity.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment